Original size 960x1369

A city for a resident or for a service?

Longread translated automatically

Two o’clock in the morning in Moscow. Some need ice, some need a bandage, and some need breakfast before the cafes open.

Fifteen minutes later, a courier with a package stands outside the door. The city no longer observes curfews, and this is considered a convenience.That same summer in Barcelona, tourists with their suitcases were greeted with water guns. Columns holding signs reading «Tourist Go Home» and «Tourism is Robbing Us» lined the Sagrada Família. Similar scenes unfolded in Venice, Lisbon, Palermo, and on the islands. The two ends of Europe are moving in opposite directions. Moscow adjusts itself to the demands of those who order things. The southern cities are trying to reclaim themselves for the people who live there.In both cases, the dispute is about one thing: who should be considered dominant in the city. It has several votes, and each one looks at the door with the package in its own way.

Ice at two in the morning

Victoria lives in Moscow and values convenience without reservation.

«24/7 services are incredibly convenient, especially when living in a metropolis—you never know what you might need: ice at two in the morning, a bandage at five in the morning, or breakfast at any time and place.»

Behind this is infrastructure that the city developed ahead of others. «Samokat» appeared in 2018, and «Yandex Lavka» in 2019. Both operate through dark stores—small warehouses located in various districts where pickers, instead of customers, operate, and orders are delivered to the door in mere minutes. Fifteen minutes is the promise that prompted the dense placement of these warehouses.

The same concept swept across the West shortly after but did not last long. From 2020 to 2021, rapid delivery seemed like a new gold rush: in 2021 alone, roughly $5.5 billion was invested in European grocery delivery services. Berlin’s Gorillas grew from a startup into a unicorn company in eighteen months before being acquired by the Turkish Getir for nearly $1.2 billion. When interest rates rose and cheap money dried up in 2022, almost all these services shut down, leaving tens of thousands of pickers and couriers unemployed. Moscow, however, retained its dark store network and established it as a habit.

Victoria speaks calmly about the operational aspect. «No, demand creates supply; people voluntarily agree to this work and earn extra money. It’s like a taxi service—it also operates around the clock, and if that’s exploitation, then a taxi service is also exploitation. But people use it, and thanks to the demand, people can earn money at any time of day.»

Couriers do earn a living. In major cities, migrant workers primarily handle deliveries, with incomes reported in the range of 47–85 thousand rubles. However, the higher end of that range is achieved by working sixteen-hour shifts, and a platform can dismiss an employee with two clicks—without discussion or severance pay.

Too simple

Claire from France rarely uses delivery services and finds little convenience in them. «Sometimes it’s great to get food or clothes quickly, especially after a long workday, but it’s too easy. Because of that, you want to cook less, go out less, and socialize less.»

She speaks about working conditions as a personal choice.

«I don’t use Uber Eats because I know these workers are underpaid, and their health suffers because of their job. I don’t want to contribute to that. It should be our responsibility as customers: either be kind to them or stop using the service. We should really think twice before using such a service.»

Regarding shops closed on Sundays, Claire is more nuanced in her perspective. She understands parents who need to run errands with their children on the weekend. However, she also sees the closed door as a respite for those who would otherwise be forced to work Sundays and nights.

Henri from Strasbourg is more direct. «In France, everything depends on the city. Strasbourg is the exception; everything is closed on Sundays here; in Paris, you can shop on Sunday, but most stores close around 11 PM.» This difference stems from history: from 1871 to 1918, Alsace and part of Lorraine were part of the German Empire, and upon returning to France, they retained some local laws. Among the surviving German regulations are strict Sunday rest rules, which is why Strasbourg’s shops remain closed on weekends to this day. While Henri’s point about convenience is valid, he draws a clear line.

«I wish the stores in Strasbourg would be open on Sundays. But not 24/7—you don’t need to shop after nine p.m., and that creates problems for those who work night shifts.» He does not use delivery; he picks up food himself by bicycle. «There is a lot of hypocrisy in France surrounding couriers: usually, they are undocumented migrants without social protection or labor rights.» In Moscow, these people are called self-employed; in France, they are called illegal.

Barcelona responds

In Southern Europe, the primary debate revolves around housing. In June 2024, Barcelona Mayor Jaume Collboni announced that the city would no longer renew licenses for short-term rentals, intending to return roughly 10,000 tourist apartments to residents by November 2028. Airbnb and property owners challenged the decision, but the Spanish Constitutional Court dismissed their arguments in the spring of 2025. The reason, according to the Mayor, was statistical: rental prices in the city have increased by 68% over ten years. Barcelona receives 26 million tourists annually, compared to a population of 1.7 million.

Lisbon followed a similar path earlier. The «golden visa» program and tax incentives turned historic neighborhoods into objects of speculation: between 2014 and 2024, housing prices in the city rose by 176%. In Alfama, the most tourist-heavy district, homes were successively converted into short-term rentals, local residents moved out, and regular shops were replaced by souvenir stores and cafes for visitors.

Venice illustrates the ultimate outcome. In the 1970s, around 175,000 people lived in the historic center; now, fewer than 48,000 remain—activists, citing municipal data, specify the number as 47,995. Yet, the city receives 20 million tourists per year, with nearly eighty percent leaving the same day. There are now more guest accommodations in the city than permanent residents. Since April 2024, Venice has implemented a €5 entrance fee on peak days—an attempt to somehow repel the crowds from its own streets.

The summer of 2025 linked these cities with a single wave of protest. On June 15th, coordinated demonstrations against overtourism took place in Barcelona, Lisbon, Venice, Palermo, and throughout the islands. These protests were organized by the SET network—an association of Southern European neighborhoods against touristification established back in 2017. The residents shared one central concern: the city had been redesigned for the visitor, leaving no space for its own inhabitants.

However, the opposition has its counterargument. Airbnb proponents point out that bans alone do not reduce prices, and that tourist flow continues to increase even in areas where rentals have already been restricted. Housing costs are rising due to numerous factors, and short-term rentals are only one of them.

The Home of the Gig Economy Makes a Stand

Britain came up with Deliveroo and Uber Eats, and the Moscow model is closer to those concepts. What’s more interesting is what Brad from Bristol says. «With the development of technology in Bristol, there has been more work like Deliveroo and Uber. The change was gradual—it didn’t happen suddenly. I wouldn’t change all of it, but the behavior of delivery services—yes: in fast food, customers in the dining area are moved aside for online orders, and bags of food left on the floor are placed on tables where food is served.»

Brad hasn’t personally encountered Airbnb, but he understands the dissatisfaction—it’s about housing and rentals. He says that in Britain, the laws protect couriers and drivers, and that’s an important difference from France and Russia. But when asked which pole his city is closer to, he answers without hesitation.

«We are closer to Barcelona. And I would like it to be closer to Barcelona. I don’t think mixed shifts are beneficial for people.»

Person at the Door

Original size 1920x1080

Photo: RG72

Moscow and Barcelona answer the same question with opposing tools. One city is structured so that demand arrives organically, leaving no need to inquire. The other meticulously counts apartments and licenses to bring back into view those who have been rendered invisible by rental markets and tourism.

Someone pays for both the Moscow convenience and the Barcelona vacation. In one case, it is a courier who works a sixteen-hour shift for 85 thousand. In the other, it is a neighbor whose apartment was converted into a guest rental ten years ago, and who was himself written out of the city along with the rental fee. Venice already knows what the ending looks like: fewer than 48 thousand residents and tourist lodging spots instead of neighbors.

Therefore, the dispute always boils down to one scene. Two o’clock in the morning, a knock on the door, a person with a package on the threshold. Victoria sees a worker who chose their shift themselves. Claire—someone one at least has to greet. Barcelona is the figure for whom city rules should be rewritten. The door opens. Who is really standing behind it—none of them ever asked.

A city for a resident or for a service?
Project created at 23.06.2026
More projects in urban studies
Vera Ilina
В центре Москвы земля стоит до четырёх миллионов рублей за метр, а дома на ней стоят пустыми.
Inna Surova Viktorovna
Дисгармония стилей, материалов и масштабов, но эта картина — метафора самого города, где старые кварталы соседствуют с современными высотками, а суета будней растворяется в красоте неба на рассвете. Помните это утреннее состояние, когда небо такое звенящее, воздух ещё чистый, а машины уже во всю спешат на работу? Может в следующий раз, утром, по пути на работу вы посмотрите вверх на нежный перелив облаков и вспомните эту картину. Вживую она ещё интереснее и ближе. Холст, масло, 70×40 см, Краснодар, 2022 год.
creativecity.academy
events
travelling
history
art and design
Show more
We use cookies to improve the operation of the HSE website and to enhance its usability. More detailed information on the use of cookies can be fou...
Show more