how the rejection of ideal beauty became a new aesthetic standard in fashion photography from the 1990s to the 2020s.
Navigator
[1] Concept [2] The Ideal: Aesthetic of Perfection [2.1] Richard Avedon [2.2] Irving Penn [3] Anti-Gloss: Aesthetic of Imperfection [3.1] Corinne Day [3.2] Jürgen Teller [4] The Dictatorship of Imperfection: From Protest to a New Standard [4.1] Marc Jacobs — Jürgen Teller’s advertising campaigns [4.2] Diesel — Go With The Flaw (2017) [4.3] Gucci — Reimagining Traditional Beauty [5] Conclusion [6] Bibliography [7] Image Sources
Concept
For decades, the concepts of beauty in fashion photography were rooted in the pursuit of perfection. Flawless skin, harmonious proportions, meticulously constructed composition, and controlled lighting shaped an idealized human image. However, by the end of the 20th century, an opposing aesthetic began to proliferate within visual culture. Unconventional features, natural bodily characteristics, careless posing, and technical imperfections started to become independent means of artistic expression.
The paradox is that imperfection, initially set against traditional standards of beauty, gradually transforms into an aesthetic standard itself. Random angles, harsh flash, the absence of retouching, and deliberate carelessness begin to be intentionally reproduced in fashion photography and advertising campaigns.The suggestion arises that modern visual culture does not so much reject the ideal as it alters the principles of its creation: flawless perfection is being replaced by meticulously constructed naturalness.
The study examines the ways beauty and imperfection are depicted in fashion photography and advertising from the 1990s to 2020s. For the analysis, works by Richard Avedon, Irving Penn, Corinne Day, and Jürgen Teller were selected, alongside advertising campaigns by Marc Jacobs, Diesel, and Gucci. This material selection was motivated by the opportunity to compare three fundamentally different approaches to portraying beauty: traditional glossy idealization, anti-gloss aesthetics, and the commercial utilization of artistic techniques of imperfection.
How does imperfection—which emerges as a counterpoint to idealized beauty—transform into a new aesthetic standard, and what role does the deliberate replication of visual carelessness play in this transformation?
The hypothesis is that contemporary aesthetics of imperfection do not negate the ideal of beauty, but rather shift it from the depicted object to the manner of depiction. While traditional gloss sought visual perfection in the human subject, anti-gloss photography begins to aestheticize imperfection itself. Naturalness, randomness, and carelessness are transformed into conscious artistic techniques that eventually develop stable visual characteristics. Thus, contrasting with traditional aesthetic norms can lead to the formation of new rules. Imperfection ceases to be solely a violation of the ideal and becomes an object of idealization in itself.
The research is divided into three analytical parts, sequentially revealing the transformation of perceptions of beauty in fashion photography.
Part One—“The Ideal» examines the principles of traditional glossy photography through the work of Richard Avedon and Irving Penn. The primary focus is on the idealization of appearance, staging, and visual flawlessness.
Part Two—“Anti-Gloss» is dedicated to the emergence of an alternative artistic language. Using the photographs of Corinne Day and Jürgen Teller, it investigates the transformation of naturalness, carelessness, and visual imperfections into means of artistic expression.
Part Three—“The Dictatorship of Imperfection» examines the transition of anti-gloss aesthetics into commercial photography. Comparing advertising campaigns by Marc Jacobs, Diesel, and Gucci allows us to trace how intentional imperfection transforms into a recognizable visual trope.
The theoretical foundation of this research is Roland Barthes’s work Camera Lucida (1980), which examines the nature of the photographic image and the peculiarities of its perception. Additionally, Susan Sontag’s essay collection On Photography (1977) is reviewed, analyzing the influence of photography on the perception and aestheticization of reality. To understand the transition of alternative artistic techniques into a commercial visual language, Dick Hebdige’s Subculture: The Meaning of Style (1979) is utilized, which focuses on the symbolism of subcultural styles and their integration into mass culture.
Ideal. The Aesthetics of Perfection
The seemingly familiar image of ideal beauty in fashion photography is rarely accidental. Beneath the flawless silhouettes, expressive poses, and apparent ease lies a meticulously constructed reality where even movement serves the photographer’s vision.
Richard Avedon
Richard Averdon. «Dovima with Elephants, ” 1955.
In one of Richard Avedon’s most famous photographs, a graceful female figure is positioned between two enormous elephants. The contrast seems almost impossible: the lightness of the dress is set against the heaviness of the animals, the smoothness of the fabric against rough skin, and the model’s elongated arms against massive forms.
Yet, the stronger this contrast, the more perfect Dovima appears. She seems to exist by different laws—the surrounding reality only serves to emphasize her refinement.
Here, beauty is created not only by the model’s appearance but also by how the photographer organizes the entire space around her.
Richard Avedon. «Carmen. Homage to Munch, ” 1957.
In the photograph «Carmen, ” Avedon transports the model from the hypothetical space of a staged shoot to the city street. Instead of a static pose, there is a step; instead of a tranquil silhouette, there is a billowing coat. It seems the photographer caught a moment by chance. But if you look closer: the movement of the legs, the position of the umbrella, and the direction of the fabric create an astonishingly harmonious composition.
Avedon demonstrates that ideal beauty can be dynamic. It no longer requires stillness—it is enough for even the shortest moment to appear perfect.
Never pose your subjects. Let them move naturally.
The Munkachi concept seems contrary to staged photography: allowing the model to move naturally, without restricting them to a preconceived pose. However, in Avedon’s work, an interesting contradiction emerges. The photography appears spontaneous, yet its visual harmony makes one question the complete randomness of the events. It turns out that naturalness and control do not necessarily exclude each other. Sometimes it is precisely their combination that allows for the creation of the most convincing ideal image.
Richard Avedon. «Verushka in a Bill Blass Dress,» New York, 1967.
In photography, Verushka’s movement ceases to be merely a way to enliven an image. It becomes the primary artistic tool. The model’s figure acquires an almost sculptural expressiveness. The elongated lines of the body, the unconventional pose, and the movement of the fabric create a silhouette that feels simultaneously human and fantastical.
If in Dovima’s photograph the ideal was accentuated by its surroundings, and in «Carmen» by the harmony of movement, here Avedon seems to construct a new beauty by exaggerating the possibilities of the human body.The ideal is no longer bound to conform to everyday reality. It can exist purely within the photograph.
All photographs are accurate. None of them is the truth.
This statement allows for a different perspective on the photographs discussed. Each one captures a real moment, yet none offers a neutral reflection of reality. Averdon chooses exactly what we will see: which proportions will appear expressive, which movement will be beautiful, and which contrast will be unexpected. Photography does not merely preserve beauty; it creates a specific representation of it.
Richard Avedon’s photographs demonstrate that perfect beauty is created not only by the model’s appearance but also by meticulously thought-out composition, movement, and perspective.
Flawlessness is not an inherent quality of reality itself, but rather the result of controlling its depiction.
Matte Finish. The Aesthetics of Imperfection
But what happens when a photographer stops striving for flawless imagery? In the 1990s, the meticulously constructed elegance gave way to an aesthetic that valued the everyday, the accidental, and the imperfect.












