Table of Contents
1. Concept 2. Mathematically Sublime 4. Dynamically Sublime 5. Limit of Perception 6. Conclusion 7. References
Concept
Stanley Kubrick’s film «2001: A Space Odyssey» (1968) is almost invariably described in terms of its technical innovation, scope, and spectacle.
This study proposes looking at it in a new way—specifically, as a visual construction of the sublime in the Kantian sense.
2001—it is a non-verbal experience… I tried to create a visual experience that bypasses verbal labels and directly penetrates the subconscious with emotional and philosophical content.
Kubrick doesn’t just depict space; he constructs an experience where the viewer’s imagination confronts its own limit. The inability to encompass infinity, the awe before the power of artificial intelligence, the geometric inaccessibility of the monolith, and the impossibility of understanding another mind—all these examples fit perfectly within what the German philosopher Immanuel Kant defined long before the first human flight into space as das Erhabene—the sublime.
The research hypothesis is that the visual language of «Cosmic Odyssey» should be understood as an independent narrative of the sublime, which impacts the viewer not so much through plot and symbols, but through the organization of the frame and sequence.
In this study, I examine how Kubrick constructs the sublime on three levels:
Mathematically sublime—through scale, emptiness, perspective, and the disproportion between humanity and the cosmos.
Dynamically sublime—through hidden threat, silence, isolation, the monolith, and HAL as an image of the limits of rationality.
The limit of perception—through «2001: A Space Odyssey» and its finale, where familiar optics break down and the viewer transitions from reasoned contemplation to internal shock.
All three levels form a unified system—a unique cinematic fabric capable of evoking in the viewer a sense of connection to something greater than what the mind or imagination can grasp.
This division ensures a seamless transition from the mathematically and dynamically elevated elements through to the film’s concluding episode, where catharsis occurs—a perception pushed to its limits that generates a complex emotional response, surprisingly combining both concepts.
This approach allows us to test the hypothesis on different levels and demonstrate how they work together, preparing the viewer for the film’s climax.
To test the hypothesis, film criticism articles, author interviews, and academic literature were utilized. Following this, individual frames from the film were analyzed, examining the compositional, color, and lighting solutions employed within them, and their correspondence to the philosophical categories of Immanuel Kant was identified.
Chapter 1. Mathematically Sublime
The concept of the sublime in Kant’s terminology is primarily linked to the concept of imagination. Imagination is the capacity to represent an object without its presence in sensory experience. For Kant, imagination acts as a bridge connecting the abstract concepts of reason with the concrete images of sensibility.
It is at the intersection of imagination’s disproportion with the idea of the whole—a totality so vast that it cannot be grasped in a single contemplation—that the feeling of the mathematically sublime is born.
As imagination strives to comprehend the infinite, it reaches its maximum and, upon attempting to expand beyond it, retreats inward, simultaneously experiencing a feeling of gentle benevolence. [1]
Contemplating space, its boundless stellar expanse that surpasses all the limits of our comprehension—this is one of the illustrative examples Immanuel Kant used to convey this feeling.
Gazing at shots of outer space receding toward the edges of the screen, we feel our own insignificance in comparison. This feeling is amplified by the slow camera movement and the deliberate expanse of the scene.
Kubrick masterfully employs perspective and negative space as a means to convey mathematical sublimity. Human structures, such as the ship Discovery One and the space station, appear fragile and small against the backdrop of infinity. There is no horizon or reference point in the frame that allows the eye to establish scale. The imagination attempts to grasp the object, yet the surrounding void reminds us that the whole is incommensurable with any figure it can outline.
The view of our planet from space would undoubtedly have captivated Kant had he been able to observe it, as it reshapes our perception of the scale of the world we inhabit. On one hand, we are struck with the awe of realizing that our Earth is merely a tiny grain of sand in the boundless ocean of the universe; on the other, we marvel at the beauty of that grain—the strength of the human spirit capable of sustaining an entire planet for life.
A similar feeling arises from contemplating the lunar landscapes, whose vast, untamed expanse inspires awe.
The classical music accompanying these scenes sustains a sense of grandeur and magnificence in the contemplation. Furthermore, the solemnity of its sound assists the reflective capacity—in conjunction with reason—to overcome initial feelings of oppression and fear, transforming them into intellectual and aesthetic pleasure.
It is sublime—one possibility of thought that proves the soul’s capacity to transcend any scale of feeling.
I want to specifically mention the beginning of the film, the segment «Dawn of Humanity.» Here, we see the Earth as a wild, sun-drenched desert. Gazing upon its still uninhabited expanse, it is difficult to speak of any human grandeur. By what fate was humanity abandoned here?
Nevertheless, it is here that perhaps one of the most beautiful transitions in cinematic history occurs—an apex of mathematical sublimity—the roll of a die spanning millions of years. The scale of human history is compressed into a single montage cut, and we feel the boundless temporal depth separating us from the origins of the world.
Our imagination is as incapable of grasping the endless flow of time as it is of comprehending the immensity of cosmic space. It is here that we experience the feeling Kant describes as «pensive benevolence"—the pleasure derived from the mind’s capacity to conceive of this boundlessness, even if the imagination cannot visualize it.
Chapter 2. Dynamically Sublime
Test
